The Psychology Behind Openable Surprises
Why a message you open feels different from one you read: what research on curiosity, uncertainty and gratitude says, and how to use it without overdoing it.
A wrapped present and the same present handed over in a shop bag are the same object. Most people still feel the first one more. Messages work the same way. A message that has to be opened, even for two seconds, is received differently from one that is simply read. Psychology research offers a few reasons why, and they also show where the effect stops.
This article sums up what the studies found, in plain words, and what it means for the next message you send.
Why does a surprise you open feel different?
Three things happen with an openable surprise that do not happen with a plain text. It creates a short moment of curiosity before the message. It leaves a little uncertainty about what is coming. And it shows the person you made something for them. Each of these has been studied on its own.
Curiosity: the gap before the message
In a 1994 review in Psychological Bulletin, the economist and psychologist George Loewenstein described curiosity as the feeling that comes from noticing a gap in what we know (Loewenstein, 1994). Once we see the gap, we want to close it. A closed envelope with your name on it is a small gap. So is a link that says "I made you something" without saying what.
The gap has to be small and clearly closable. A message that hides too much, or makes someone work for it, turns curiosity into annoyance. An openable surprise works when the gap lasts seconds: their name, one small action, then the words.
Uncertainty: why a little mystery lasts longer
In a 2005 study in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, Timothy Wilson, Daniel Gilbert and their colleagues handed people a small card with a dollar coin attached (Wilson et al., 2005). Some cards explained who was giving them and why. Others only asked "Who are we?" and "Why do we do this?". People who got the card that left those questions open stayed in a good mood longer than those who got the full explanation.
The researchers called it the pleasure of uncertainty: once we fully explain a nice event, we stop thinking about it. Most people do not expect this, which is why we tend to give everything away in the first line. For a surprise message, it suggests keeping the main news for the end, not for the notification preview.
Being thought of: the part we underestimate
In a 2018 study in Psychological Science, Amit Kumar and Nicholas Epley asked people to write a letter of thanks to someone who had mattered to them, and to predict how the person would react (University of Chicago summary). The writers underestimated how surprised the recipients would be by what they wrote, underestimated how positive they would feel, and overestimated how awkward they would feel.
That is the part of a surprise that has nothing to do with animation. The effect comes from someone learning that you noticed something about them. The opening only makes sure they pay attention when they find out.
What this means for your message
- Keep the gap short. A few seconds of curiosity is pleasant. A puzzle is a chore.
- Save the main line for last. Many apps show the first words in the notification. Let the opening line set the scene and the last line carry the news or the feeling.
- Make the reveal match the moment. Popping balloons suits a birthday. Wiping fog off a window suits someone you miss. A mismatched reveal feels like a gimmick.
- Put the effort in the words. Research on gratitude points to the content: what you noticed, and that you said it.
Where the effect stops
An openable surprise is not better for every message. Bad news, urgent practical information and anything someone needs to read quickly should arrive plainly. Making a person tap through an animation to learn something serious is unkind, not clever. And no reveal makes a generic message personal. The research above is about attention and feeling, and both run out quickly when the words underneath say nothing.
How an openable surprise is built
On Let me say, every surprise follows the pattern the studies point to. The link preview shows their name and never your message, so the notification keeps the gap. When they open it, they see their name and something to do first: a ring box to open, a broken bowl to mend, a fortune cookie to crack, depending on the occasion. Then your words appear. Each animation has its own sound effects, and the whole thing can be replayed or kept as a video.
For the writing side, see how to write a message that opens like a gift, and for news you want to reveal, surprise reveal messages.
A short gap, one honest line at the end. Make a surprise to open.